Our Diamond Guarantee

Our Promise to You

There are no buy-back guarantees on auction sites or Craig’s List.

We're different.

We want you to be completely happy with your diamond purchase. If you buy a diamond ring on I Do Now I Don't and decide it's not for you, we'll buy it back based on the following:

  1. You return the diamond ring to I Do Now I Don't within ten days of receipt by you.
  2. Our gemologist confirms that the diamond and setting are identical to the ring we sent you.
  3. We provide you with a one-time credit that can be used to make another purchase exclusively on I Do Now I Don't within 30 days. The credit will be calculated as the wholesale price for the diamond per the industry-standard Rappaport Diamond Report minus 45%. For example, a diamond valued at $5,000 by Rappaport would entitle you to a $2,750 credit on I Do Now I Don’t.

For more information click here >>

CATEGORIES

Our Gemologist Checks Every Gemstone

Every diamond and gemstone sold through I Do Now I Don’t is analyzed by a GIA-trained gemologist.

GUARANTEED: Your purchase payment WILL NOT BE RELEASED TO THE SELLER until our gemologist has given her expert's seal of approval.

Click to Continue >>

Our Founder’s Story

I had met the love of my life, and it was time to settle down. So, I picked out the most beautiful
and expensive engagement ring I could afford- a flawless diamond of more than two carats, set in a platinum band.

Does this sound familiar? A few months later, after a tough day at work, I came home to find....

Click to Continue >>

ATTN Sellers - We'll Make You an Offer on the Spot

Do you have a diamond ring with a GIA, EGL, AGSL or IGI certificate? Simply include that certificate number with your FREE listing. We may be able to make you an offer on the spot.

Click to Continue >>

What the Media Has to Say



We have made hundreds of buyers and sellers of jewelry, diamond rings, even wedding dresses very happy. And the national press has taken notice.

From Rachael Ray to Glenn Beck of CNN, from The Boston Globe to CBS-TV, the news media loves our founder’s broken-engagement-into-a-new-business story and the amazing value we provide.

Click to Continue >>